Spilled Milk Ice Cream - Reviews skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

The service was excellent. Friendly, fast, helpful. The custom-built mixer machines were cool to watch. My kids loved the cones. We tried several different flavors. I had an ice cream sandwich that was huge.
Todd Beck via google.com - Nov 26, 2021
Super yummy ice cream. Wish they had a location up north!
Erin Udink via google.com - Nov 24, 2021
Pro-tip: Besides for the premade options, you can make your own. It's not well advertised, but you c
Pro-tip: Besides for the premade options, you can make your own. It's not well advertised, but you can choose an unlimited number of toppings - some can be mixed in and some are just added on top. They recommend only mixing in three different toppings though otherwise the soft serve will be gritty. Highlights: Really neat concept, bu ... read more
Winnie L. via yelp.com - Nov 14, 2021
We were in town and when I came across this place I knew that we had to stop in. First, I absolutely love local places like this! The flavors were quite unique but I settled on a fried ice cream shake and it was out of this world. The combination of ice cream and cereal is a winner every time. It was just the perfect sweet dessert th ... read more
Mark Yambor via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
I can have milk and cereal for dinner and be happy. Therefore, coming here for ice cream and cereal
I can have milk and cereal for dinner and be happy. Therefore, coming here for ice cream and cereal (for dinner or not) makes me even happier. Not only are there fun flavors of ice cream, there are also fun flavors for cones, like red velvet, coconut, orange creamsicle, or green matcha. I have not tried their milk shakes yet, but wou ... read more
Ally W. via yelp.com - Nov 11, 2021
This is a fun ice cream bar to visit for children AND adults! Spilled Milk mixes ice cream, cereal,
This is a fun ice cream bar to visit for children AND adults! Spilled Milk mixes ice cream, cereal, and classic candies with ice cream. It was a little difficult to make a decision and decided to just try a bunch. We tried the "Over the rainbow", "Match made in Heaven", and "Banana dream pie". We definitely had a great time with thes ... read more
Caroline N. via yelp.com - Nov 11, 2021
Visited on Sunday. Spent time on Salt Lake before a flight and wow. Every person I was with couldn't
Visited on Sunday. Spent time on Salt Lake before a flight and wow. Every person I was with couldn't stop talking about how amazing our dessert was. I am a cereal fanatic and this was everything. I did the make your own cone with fruit loop ice cream and lucky charm marshmallows on top. Perfection. The others got shakes (best one was ... read more
Samantha B. via yelp.com - Nov 9, 2021
Spilled Milk has such a fun idea - mixing cereal (and other toppings) in with ice cream, sort of Col
Spilled Milk has such a fun idea - mixing cereal (and other toppings) in with ice cream, sort of Coldstone-style. For a first-timer, the menu is a bit confusing and it isn't explained how the ice cream is presented (some toppings are on top, some are mixed in.) I wish they would've had a bit more breakdown on the menu or from an empl ... read more
Kelsey C. via yelp.com - Oct 30, 2021
One of the best milkshakes I have ever had!
Autumn Whittaker via google.com - Oct 26, 2021
The strawberry milkshake was so good ... read more
Una Phillips via google.com - Oct 25, 2021
I'm lactose intolerant but this ice cream was worth my stomach pains. Made with whole milk and all t
I'm lactose intolerant but this ice cream was worth my stomach pains. Made with whole milk and all the amazing toppings...I'm not creative so I had the raspberry, almond on vanilla ice cream and it was delish!! Usually ice cream at such gourmet-make-your-own types of places will be super sweet but Spilled Milk had the balance just ri ... read more
Vic P. via yelp.com - Oct 24, 2021
I came in under the impression that these guys were going to load my ice cream up with a ton of Mix-
I came in under the impression that these guys were going to load my ice cream up with a ton of Mix-ins. I have a friend that told me not to go because these guys over-do it. Now that sounded pretty darn good to me. It sounded like he was complaining that their was too much awesome in his ice cream. So I set out to obtain some of thi ... read more
Justin D. via yelp.com - Oct 22, 2021
This place is so unique and delicious. I stop by any time I'm in the area. They even have vegan opti
This place is so unique and delicious. I stop by any time I'm in the area. They even have vegan options.
Dani H. via yelp.com - Oct 13, 2021
I don't know how I have never considered combing ice cream and cereal. What a genius idea! The store itself is clean, minimally designed, and very cute. Great service and great desserts. Would recommend ... read more
Hawkin Saeger via google.com - Oct 10, 2021
It wasn't busy when we came in around 2:30p on a Thursday. The menu felt limited, but were able to f
It wasn't busy when we came in around 2:30p on a Thursday. The menu felt limited, but were able to find something that we liked. We love the different flavors and colors of the cone. They have generous size of rice Crispy Treats and Milkshakes on the menu. There weren't enough parking spots, but it didn't seem like a busy area so we' ... read more
Maria M. via yelp.com - Oct 6, 2021
Really good ice cream!! This is a cool spot with creative ice cream cones and shakes. I recommend th
Really good ice cream!! This is a cool spot with creative ice cream cones and shakes. I recommend the kids one bc it was only $4 and it was still plenty big. It was kind of a long wait but they were working hard to get them out as quickly as possible. It was just a really busy night so not going to hold it against them. $7 for regula ... read more
Austin G. via yelp.com - Oct 2, 2021
Delicious. Instagram-worthy. Open late. The three best ways to describe this place! Definitely check
Delicious. Instagram-worthy. Open late. The three best ways to describe this place! Definitely check it out if you're in SLC.
Amanda R. via yelp.com - Sep 29, 2021
Such a cute place and significantly more enjoyable than I expected. I didn't expect the cereal to li
Such a cute place and significantly more enjoyable than I expected. I didn't expect the cereal to literally be blended into the ice cream, but it was great. I also felt that the price was reasonable for the amount of ice cream you receive. I was stuffed after eating it. The people behind the counter were kind and quick. I'd definitel ... read more
Corinn S. via yelp.com - Sep 18, 2021
One of the best ice cream places I’ve been to whenever I go to downtown. I tried the Fun-Fetti ice cream sandwich and it was so good and on point. My brother tried the match made in heaven ice cream and said he liked it. I would go to this place again.
Kevin Ly via google.com - Sep 16, 2021
This is a great concept that I was happy that made its way west after I tried it in NYC several years ago. My main issue with spilled milk is that it seems more focused on making instagramable ice cream than truly delicious ice cream. The menu never changes and the creative artistry that would take spilled milk to the next level just ... read more
Ethan Smith via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
Went there on a Saturday night and they were a little busy but handled the rush amazingly. I’ve cream was really good and presented well. Definitely recommend visiting.
Corey Stock via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
Seriously... Like walking into heaven.... It's smells sooooooo good in there! Excellent portions and great flavors!
natalia moreno via google.com - Sep 3, 2021
Our first time visiting and looking at the menu doesn't do the ice cream justice. The menu looks strange when you don't know what it translates to in reality. The ice cream is delicious! It's a very unique and interesting concept. It's not sickeningly sweet which was my first thought seeing all the cereal options. Try the Berry Delic ... read more
L L via google.com - Sep 1, 2021
I'm willing to kill for this creamy face funk. This shit is like the cocaine of ice cream. Fuck what
I'm willing to kill for this creamy face funk. This shit is like the cocaine of ice cream. Fuck what cha heard. This place will face fuck you. Pull your hair . Slap your ass cheeks and tell you that you've been a naughty little whore. It's so good. Shits filling so don't go crazy buying alot. A one scoop or specialty cone will suffic ... read more
Jesse S. via yelp.com - Sep 1, 2021
Their ice cream is light in the best of ways!
Lawrence Stowers via google.com - Aug 29, 2021
Such a fun place!!
Jake T via google.com - Aug 28, 2021
Yes! All about this place. The innovative flavor pairings, the interior decor, the freaking bomb ice
Yes! All about this place. The innovative flavor pairings, the interior decor, the freaking bomb ice cream. Wish I would have taken photos that did the place justice.
Haylee A. via yelp.com - Aug 21, 2021
Very friendly staff, great ice cream, good environment.
Caleb Meyer via google.com - Aug 18, 2021
Ice cream was pretty good but the atmosphere wasn't good because all the workers seemed angry ... read more
S Rey via google.com - Aug 18, 2021
I’ve been to the food truck and was happy with that experience so I decided to try out the shop! Everything was delicious and my portion size was huge-but my friends was a lot smaller than mine so I guess it depends on who makes yours. So maybe they need some consistency. Also, the menu advertises different cone flavors and the day I ... read more
Karissa Horning via google.com - Aug 16, 2021
We came to Spilled Milk when it was just one lonely truck in the Macey's parking lot. I was excited
We came to Spilled Milk when it was just one lonely truck in the Macey's parking lot. I was excited to try their brick location after a Bee's game. It was really busy, so I was concerned about the wait. I'll say the cashier helping us acted like he would've preferred to be just about anywhere else. But our ice cream was really good a ... read more
Janae I. via yelp.com - Aug 16, 2021
We tried this ice cream place last Saturday and it is so good! It’s a super fun date night treat, and the ice cream is fun and interesting. It may sound a little weird because their mix ins are cereal, but everyone in our group loved what they got.
Jonathan Williams via google.com - Aug 15, 2021
Delicious! We visited the food truck in the Dan’s parking lot in Cottonwood Heights. Soooo good and it even had vegan options!
Anna McNamer via google.com - Aug 14, 2021
Really good ice cream but its expensive, 7.51$ for an ice cream cone is so expensive but it is prett
Really good ice cream but its expensive, 7.51$ for an ice cream cone is so expensive but it is pretty unique so in my opinion its worth it.
Katie H. via yelp.com - Aug 11, 2021
Fast service with awesome flavors! Ice cream is smooth. Waffle cones are fantastic.
Joshua Jamias via google.com - Aug 10, 2021
We were so happy to find out that Spilled Milk was open on Sunday and open LATE. They closed at 10pm
We were so happy to find out that Spilled Milk was open on Sunday and open LATE. They closed at 10pm. This was my first time trying Spilled Milk and I was actually very impressed. By the looks of it, it looks kinda plain, but I didn't know that they actually make the ice cream right then and there, and they mix in the cereals and wha ... read more
Sarah L. via yelp.com - Aug 9, 2021
"Fried ice cream" was everything I wanted in a soft serve ice cream novelty ... read more
NingLi Loken via google.com - Aug 8, 2021
The fact that they make a gluten free cone is so stellar--I can't even. I've been gluten free for 5
The fact that they make a gluten free cone is so stellar--I can't even. I've been gluten free for 5 years now, and finding this tonight was like finding a pot of gold. Its made of coconut! If you're gluten free, run to this establishment right now. They also had a dairy-free option. Some say it's a little bland, I say throw some cere ... read more
Brenna L. via yelp.com - Aug 6, 2021
What a fun little place this is. Decor is spot on and they have a large staff so you will not have t
What a fun little place this is. Decor is spot on and they have a large staff so you will not have to wait long to order or get your ice cream. They have many odd but great combinations to choose from. Check out their menu! Very nice addition to this already great neighborhood.
Brandon N. via yelp.com - Aug 4, 2021
Very good ice cream ! Good prices!! Fun selection!
Dave Evans via google.com - Aug 3, 2021
Rad spot! Has a unique blend of cereal with ice cream. Highly recommend to try it!
3kProductions via google.com - Jul 31, 2021
Obsessed. I have been looking for a place like this since moving back to Utah 10+ years ago. The ice
Obsessed. I have been looking for a place like this since moving back to Utah 10+ years ago. The ice cream is my absolute favorite in the city. Love the menu options as well as the ability to create our own. The inside decor is so cute!!! Would love a pop up in city creek!!! Or gateway...
Jen R. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2021
This place is phenomenal! My wife got a delicious dairy-free ice cream, but I don't think you can go wrong with anything on the menu.
Skyler Warner via google.com - Jul 24, 2021
Have you ever been taken to try a new place by some friends that have been there before, and they wa
Have you ever been taken to try a new place by some friends that have been there before, and they walk up and order since they know what they want as you frantically scan the menu, wanting to make an informed decision and get the best item, but then a family walks in behind you and you start feeling a paralyzing fear, and you are gri ... read more
Sean R. via yelp.com - Jul 22, 2021
We LOVE this place. They mix different kinds of cereal into your soft serve ice cream so that every
We LOVE this place. They mix different kinds of cereal into your soft serve ice cream so that every bite tastes like a sweet bite of cereal. I always get the "Over the Rainbow" because I'm a fruity pebbles guy. Their cocoa pebbles ice cream sandwich was disappointing. It seemed like they made it earlier that day and had it frozen rea ... read more
Rylan G. via yelp.com - Jul 19, 2021
Fun spot, great ice cream ... read more
Ike Hinckley via google.com - Jul 17, 2021
Ok such a cute place with a fun concept! I'll start by saying I am not a fan a cereal but this place
Ok such a cute place with a fun concept! I'll start by saying I am not a fan a cereal but this place was amazing. Very flavorful vanilla base ice cream with cereal toppings. I got the fried ice cream and my husband got the match made in heaven. Both were amazing but the fried ice cream was the favorite! The 9th and 9th location is su ... read more
Caroline W. via yelp.com - Jul 10, 2021
Two of my favorite food items in one, ice cream and cereal. I really can't think of anything much better. The price could be a little lower, but this combination makes me so happy that I'm not going to complain too much.
Joshua Meyers via google.com - Jul 5, 2021
Very Clean, Nice.. Too many choices 😂😂😂 Great Service ... read more
Cory Bailey via google.com - Jul 4, 2021
Dairy Queen for the instagram crowd + vegan n'ice cream option + mostly cereal based topping + waffle cones ... read more
Andrea via google.com - Jul 2, 2021
This place is amazing! Such a creative company!! The ice cream is definitely more than one person can handle, & believe me, I love my ice cream! Different options. Staff was super friendly & helpful when ordering. Love all the decor! Seating inside & outside. Will definitely be back soon!!!
Chirelle Pearson via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
Awesome ice cream!!!! Very tasty! A little on the giant side and you could share. We couldn't finish
Awesome ice cream!!!! Very tasty! A little on the giant side and you could share. We couldn't finish our ice cream but enjoyed it!
Tawni C. via yelp.com - Jun 30, 2021
Best ice cream / milk shake around!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mario sandoval via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
Biggest ice cream cone of my life. Super tasty!
Brennan Cate via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Ice cream cone bigger than my head!! Good ice cream and good vibes 🤙🏼 ... read more
Julia Parker via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
I'm not a big fan of soft serve but I was pleasantly surprised by how good this place was.
T Pham via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Really good ice cream!!!
Bob The Builder via google.com - Jun 25, 2021
Cereal infused ice cream. Couldn’t think of a better combo!
Maddy Morgan via google.com - Jun 24, 2021
It's already adding up to be one of the hottest Summers Salt Lake has had since the 70's, so it only
It's already adding up to be one of the hottest Summers Salt Lake has had since the 70's, so it only made sense to come and try out Spilled Milk and cool off. Immediately after entering the shop we were thrilled with the scenic view which is welcoming and hip. Very cool atmosphere to add to the excitement of the pleasantries you're a ... read more
Mike F. via yelp.com - Jun 23, 2021
Love it, Isabel Stevenson was a great server and she needs a raise ASAP, never seen so much hustle and genuine motivation to become better, will definitely be returning.
Austin Zimmerman via google.com - Jun 22, 2021
This place has become a favorite with my friends and I. Fun atmosphere and ice cream is top notch. If you're looking for an ice cream cone that has Instagram worthy looks but tastes the part, this is the place. Can't go wrong with whatever you order, although I really like the fruity pebbles one.
Davis Clark via google.com - Jun 18, 2021
Tastes great. Can be on the pricey side. If your up for a unique experience I would highly recommend this place for dessert. Especially on a hot summer night.
Sherrill Anderson via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
I didn't think cereal would make a good ice cream mix-in, but this place changed my mind! Yummy and a good serving size ... read more
Constance via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
Love this place. I’ve been here a lot, both the 9th and 9th store as well as the truck. One complaint I have: I ordered my milkshake for pick up at the store for 815p. It was made 45 minutes ahead of time (i received a text). When i got there, everything was runny and the toppings were very sad. But for the future: maybe don’t make o ... read more
Lily Jones via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
This place was amazing, the ice cream was so creamy and had an amazing flavor to it! I got the Berry Delicious, vanilla base with Golden Grahams and Strawberries mixed in. My boyfriend got the Match Made in Heaven with a regular cone instead of the red velvet. Both were utterly delicious and very large. Will definitely go back ag ... read more
Megan McFarland via google.com - Jun 10, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire