Spilled Milk Ice Cream - Reviews skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Obsessed. I have been looking for a place like this since moving back to Utah 10+ years ago. The ice
Obsessed. I have been looking for a place like this since moving back to Utah 10+ years ago. The ice cream is my absolute favorite in the city. Love the menu options as well as the ability to create our own. The inside decor is so cute!!! Would love a pop up in city creek!!! Or gateway...
Jen R. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2021
This place is phenomenal! My wife got a delicious dairy-free ice cream, but I don't think you can go wrong with anything on the menu.
Skyler Warner via google.com - Jul 24, 2021
Have you ever been taken to try a new place by some friends that have been there before, and they wa
Have you ever been taken to try a new place by some friends that have been there before, and they walk up and order since they know what they want as you frantically scan the menu, wanting to make an informed decision and get the best item, but then a family walks in behind you and you start feeling a paralyzing fear, and you are gri ... read more
Sean R. via yelp.com - Jul 22, 2021
We LOVE this place. They mix different kinds of cereal into your soft serve ice cream so that every
We LOVE this place. They mix different kinds of cereal into your soft serve ice cream so that every bite tastes like a sweet bite of cereal. I always get the "Over the Rainbow" because I'm a fruity pebbles guy. Their cocoa pebbles ice cream sandwich was disappointing. It seemed like they made it earlier that day and had it frozen rea ... read more
Rylan G. via yelp.com - Jul 19, 2021
Fun spot, great ice cream ... read more
Ike Hinckley via google.com - Jul 17, 2021
Ok such a cute place with a fun concept! I'll start by saying I am not a fan a cereal but this place
Ok such a cute place with a fun concept! I'll start by saying I am not a fan a cereal but this place was amazing. Very flavorful vanilla base ice cream with cereal toppings. I got the fried ice cream and my husband got the match made in heaven. Both were amazing but the fried ice cream was the favorite! The 9th and 9th location is su ... read more
Caroline W. via yelp.com - Jul 10, 2021
Two of my favorite food items in one, ice cream and cereal. I really can't think of anything much better. The price could be a little lower, but this combination makes me so happy that I'm not going to complain too much.
Joshua Meyers via google.com - Jul 5, 2021
Very Clean, Nice.. Too many choices 😂😂😂 Great Service ... read more
Cory Bailey via google.com - Jul 4, 2021
Dairy Queen for the instagram crowd + vegan n'ice cream option + mostly cereal based topping + waffle cones ... read more
Andrea via google.com - Jul 2, 2021
This place is amazing! Such a creative company!! The ice cream is definitely more than one person can handle, & believe me, I love my ice cream! Different options. Staff was super friendly & helpful when ordering. Love all the decor! Seating inside & outside. Will definitely be back soon!!!
Chirelle Pearson via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
Awesome ice cream!!!! Very tasty! A little on the giant side and you could share. We couldn't finish
Awesome ice cream!!!! Very tasty! A little on the giant side and you could share. We couldn't finish our ice cream but enjoyed it!
Tawni C. via yelp.com - Jun 30, 2021
Best ice cream / milk shake around!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mario sandoval via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
Biggest ice cream cone of my life. Super tasty!
Brennan Cate via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Ice cream cone bigger than my head!! Good ice cream and good vibes 🤙🏼 ... read more
Julia Parker via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
I'm not a big fan of soft serve but I was pleasantly surprised by how good this place was.
T Pham via google.com - Jun 26, 2021
Really good ice cream!!!
Bob The Builder via google.com - Jun 25, 2021
Cereal infused ice cream. Couldn’t think of a better combo!
Maddy Morgan via google.com - Jun 24, 2021
It's already adding up to be one of the hottest Summers Salt Lake has had since the 70's, so it only
It's already adding up to be one of the hottest Summers Salt Lake has had since the 70's, so it only made sense to come and try out Spilled Milk and cool off. Immediately after entering the shop we were thrilled with the scenic view which is welcoming and hip. Very cool atmosphere to add to the excitement of the pleasantries you're a ... read more
Mike F. via yelp.com - Jun 23, 2021
Love it, Isabel Stevenson was a great server and she needs a raise ASAP, never seen so much hustle and genuine motivation to become better, will definitely be returning.
Austin Zimmerman via google.com - Jun 22, 2021
This place has become a favorite with my friends and I. Fun atmosphere and ice cream is top notch. If you're looking for an ice cream cone that has Instagram worthy looks but tastes the part, this is the place. Can't go wrong with whatever you order, although I really like the fruity pebbles one.
Davis Clark via google.com - Jun 18, 2021
Tastes great. Can be on the pricey side. If your up for a unique experience I would highly recommend this place for dessert. Especially on a hot summer night.
Sherrill Anderson via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
I didn't think cereal would make a good ice cream mix-in, but this place changed my mind! Yummy and a good serving size ... read more
Constance via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
Love this place. I’ve been here a lot, both the 9th and 9th store as well as the truck. One complaint I have: I ordered my milkshake for pick up at the store for 815p. It was made 45 minutes ahead of time (i received a text). When i got there, everything was runny and the toppings were very sad. But for the future: maybe don’t make o ... read more
Lily Jones via google.com - Jun 17, 2021
This place was amazing, the ice cream was so creamy and had an amazing flavor to it! I got the Berry Delicious, vanilla base with Golden Grahams and Strawberries mixed in. My boyfriend got the Match Made in Heaven with a regular cone instead of the red velvet. Both were utterly delicious and very large. Will definitely go back ag ... read more
Megan McFarland via google.com - Jun 10, 2021
Really good! I got the Berry Delicious cone and it was so pretty and yummy! They take real strawberries and blend it in with the vanilla soft serve and the cereal. Just a fun, unique place to go to on a date night or with friends. Every inch of the place is very picturesque, so if you're wanting to get fun/cute pictures while getting ... read more
Kailee Nielson via google.com - Jun 3, 2021
Fun little ice cream shop that incorporates cereal into it.
crystal hunt via google.com - Jun 3, 2021
This place is so neat to watch them make your order. We did ask for a kid's size and was charged and
This place is so neat to watch them make your order. We did ask for a kid's size and was charged and given a large for my 7yo. It ended up being a waste because it was real big for him to finish. My husband ordered the Oreo Shake and I had the Nuts About Chocolate. All good and great experience but overpriced ice cream and toppings!
Ruth P. via yelp.com - Jun 3, 2021
So good!
Dallin Garber via google.com - May 27, 2021
A very Instagram worthy place. The icecream is good, but I wouldn't necessarily come here for the ic
A very Instagram worthy place. The icecream is good, but I wouldn't necessarily come here for the icecream alone... but the whole Spilled Milk experience. I got the fried Icecream! The flavor was great, the icecream was good but got a little messy, and the presentation is beautiful.!
Kimber Y. via yelp.com - May 27, 2021
This place is awesome! I ordered Saturday Morning ice cream cone and my husband got the Oreo milksha
This place is awesome! I ordered Saturday Morning ice cream cone and my husband got the Oreo milkshake. I thought it was just vanilla ice cream packed with Cap'n Crunch and Apple Jacks cereal, but it's actually both cereal blended together with ice cream. I can't describe the flavors, but it was just delicious! And I had a taste of t ... read more
Elaine L. via yelp.com - May 26, 2021
I cannot believe that I am saying this, but there are way too many toppings in the shakes. After yea
I cannot believe that I am saying this, but there are way too many toppings in the shakes. After years of complaining that no one puts enough of the good stuff Spilled Milk finally went over the top. Otherwise everyone really enjoyed their cereal themed creations.
Ryan D. via yelp.com - May 25, 2021
Amazing idea to combine ice cream and cereal! Its some of the best ice cream in SLC.
Adam Spaugy via google.com - May 24, 2021
We love spilled milk. The ice cream is DELICIOUS as are the milkshakes!! It feels so nostalgic to mix cereals I ate as a kid in my ice cream. Everyone is super friendly and I love their new store front! A definite dessert must.
E G via google.com - May 24, 2021
Our neighbor told us about this place and we were not disappointed! My wife got over the rainbow with a waffle cone and I got the match made in heaven with a dark chocolate cone. I didn’t realize the blend up some of the cereal and candy in the vanilla ice cream. I loved this place so much I’ll be back! Enjoy!
Keith Hubert via google.com - May 24, 2021
Muy rica la nieve y el servicio es excelente!!!
Rosa Salazar via google.com - May 24, 2021
Great fresh tasting ice cream. My daughters loved it. would definitely go back in the very near future. Was wondering I'm there is coupons. But great staff helpful and friendly ... read more
Jason Degregoria via google.com - May 24, 2021
It was heaven in my nose , smells like cake batter and rainbows. The staff here is awesome , out going and friendly. If you want a out of the box cereal ice cream cool down this is the place to come.
Leon Riley via google.com - May 24, 2021
I had heard great things about Spilled Milk, and they exceeded my expectations. The ice cream was perfect and the way that they incorporate cereal just brings back childhood memories. Can't wait to go back and try another combination ... read more
Chris Deitsch via google.com - May 24, 2021
My husband and I have been here 3 times in the past 2 weeks. We love it so much! We've tried the fru
My husband and I have been here 3 times in the past 2 weeks. We love it so much! We've tried the fruity pebbles cone, the nice cream cone, the fruity pebbles sandwich, and the Cinnamon Toast Crunch krispy treat (can't remember their names). Everything has been amazing! It's always clean and quick, the employees are friendly, and it's ... read more
Madison B. via yelp.com - May 10, 2021
Loved everything about this place. The creativity behind their ice cream are not only delicious but
Loved everything about this place. The creativity behind their ice cream are not only delicious but it's perfectly creamy and not too sweet! They even make flavored cones to go with the theme of ice cream you get. You can also substitute the ice cream theme you want in a form of a milkshake and they also have ice cream sandwiches. Fo ... read more
Helene D. via yelp.com - May 9, 2021
Amazing! Came 3 times in our trip to Utah! I recommend the rainbow or the fried ice cream! We loved
Amazing! Came 3 times in our trip to Utah! I recommend the rainbow or the fried ice cream! We loved everything we tried!
Sidney E. via yelp.com - May 8, 2021
This place is so fun! And popular! When we went and whenever we pass by it there is a huge line! I l
This place is so fun! And popular! When we went and whenever we pass by it there is a huge line! I love how you can choose your own toppings, love that it's more of a soft-serve ice cream (my fave), and I love the different flavors of cones. The only downside is that it's pretty expensive for an ice cream cone. My husband and I ended ... read more
Anna H. via yelp.com - May 6, 2021
Visit this place after going to Tracy Avery and because of the reviews. It hit the spot after a hot
Visit this place after going to Tracy Avery and because of the reviews. It hit the spot after a hot day. I had if I can remember correctly the N'ice cream and it was good. My friend had the Coco-licious ice cream sandwich-he enjoyed his as well. I really liked the design on the ice cream cones. But I didn't really like the cone taste ... read more
Melissa L. via yelp.com - May 4, 2021
This is my new favorite ice cream place!! At first I was a little shocked to see $7 ice cream cones,
This is my new favorite ice cream place!! At first I was a little shocked to see $7 ice cream cones, but the size and the combinations made me realize why they cost that much. These cones are all freshly made and have different flavors depending on the combinations. All have different types of cereal mixed in. We got the flavors nuts ... read more
Katie N. via yelp.com - May 1, 2021
Delicious. Amazing. Incredible. We were stoked on it all. From all their amazing shakes to the ice c
Delicious. Amazing. Incredible. We were stoked on it all. From all their amazing shakes to the ice cream sandwiches this place is a treat for sure.
Holley S. via yelp.com - Apr 29, 2021
Not a big ice cream eater, but I LOVEEEE cereal so I thought I'd try this. We got the Match made in
Not a big ice cream eater, but I LOVEEEE cereal so I thought I'd try this. We got the Match made in heaven cone and I thought I'd only want a bite or two..... but then are most of it. Loved this so much. The ice cream has so much in it it made it so good in every bite. I now need to go back and try more flavors!!
Karsen B. via yelp.com - Apr 27, 2021
After trying everything on there menu I always go back to Over the Rainbow. This place is my number 1 ice cream spot and worth the drive from where ever I'm at.
Desirae Moffett via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Overpriced? Yes. Delicious? Yes.
DJ via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Idk how nobody else had thought of the idea for this place sooner, but I’m glad they did. The ice cream is amazing, employees are way awesome and they have the best vibes in town. 5/5 ... read more
Tanner Freeman via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Best place for a date night! Not only are the ice creams trendy, they taste amazing as well. 10/10 would recommend Over The Rainbow and the Oreo milkshake. Customer service is phenomenal and we’ll be back again.
Megan Prince via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
so good I order two milkshakes at once !!
Taylor Stoker via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
If you haven't tried out this place yet for a sweet tooth... YOU ARE MISSING OUT! Honestly they have won me over for my favorite ice cream spot. Especially now that they have another location in Provo! Gotta try the Match Made in Heaven!
Jared Hickman via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Such a fun treat spot in the 9th and 9th neighborhood. The menu has lots of yummy combinations and creative come flavors.
Wendy S via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Love supporting local business! Ice cream is the best around and they are always friendly! The ice cream is addicting and unique. This is my favorite spot in Salt Lake.
Cassandra Freeman via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
I LOVE THIS PLACE! Perfect, walkable area close to shopping and Liberty Park. Great stop for a treat on a night out. And honestly, their Cinnamon Toast Crunch/fried ice cream cone is the stuff of dreams. THANK ME LATER.
Madison Bullock via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
I was skeptical at first about it being soft serve but this place is AMAZING. Super tasty, awesome staff, cool flavors and creations. 10/10 would recommend to a friend.
Mike Yerkes via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Love this edition to 9th & 9th. Very yummy treat with a great staff and atmosphere. We got the Oreo milkshake and the friend ice cream cone. Highly recommend this place for anyone with a sweet tooth.
amy alcantara via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Spilled milk? More like amazing deliciousness milk. This place is GOOOD. Take a date here and you’re almost guaranteed a 2nd date. Ask for JK. He makes some killer ice cream.
Trevor Hemsley via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Got the one with fruity pebbles, it's really ice cream dipped in cereal. Cute atmosphere, nice enough staff and they put all marshmallows on mine which is an auto win. All in all I found the flavors boring, but the idea is so cute.
Rachel Smith via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
It's bussin Janelle!
Brittany Cantrell via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
This ice cream is INCREDIBLE. seriously so creamy and the flavors were so tasty .. I normally don’t like cones... but LOVED these ones!!!
Shanda Jackson via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Best date night!! So good!!
Cam Sahely via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
I love the concept. The location is great and the texture of cereal in ice cream is an unexpected neccesity in my life. Try it now...or you will regret it.
Matt Dubois via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
I came here on a date and I got a FREE ice cream because mine fell off. They had exceptional service. Also they have VEGAN ice cream!!
Steph via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire