Spilled Milk Ice Cream - Reviews skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Very busy and had to wait 30 minutes. Was still delicious 😋 ... read more
Jennifer Michelsen via google.com - May 15, 2022
If you haven’t gone and seen what spilled milk is all about, go! Have been a dozen times and usually try to do a flavor that I haven’t tried before. Have never been disappointed.
Shawn R via google.com - May 14, 2022
this the place to be yuh, the black dude there very nice yuh! twizzy out.
Nathan Rodriguez via google.com - May 14, 2022
Went here on Tuesday with my boyfriend (Nathan Rodriguez) and it was amazing, so glad we decided to try it out. It was so good and the customer service was amazing. We were helped by this one black dude that day and he was so nice and outgoing and really showed interest in making us feel welcomed and loved, it's like we were family r ... read more
Esmeralda Elizondo via google.com - May 14, 2022
the most amazing and delicious ice-cream! we ordered only one icecream but was big enough for two pe
the most amazing and delicious ice-cream! we ordered only one icecream but was big enough for two people. great taste. thank you, if we will be back in Salt Lake City again we will definitely come back here again! X ... read more
Katie H. via yelp.com - May 8, 2022
The ic cream is a solid 10. I just wish they had an option to customize your ice cream on the menu and a vegan ice cream option.
Madison Parker via google.com - May 3, 2022
Spilled Milk Over the Rainbow Milkshake Vanilla Ice Cream, Fruity Pebbles, Cap'n Crunch, and Milk. T
Spilled Milk Over the Rainbow Milkshake Vanilla Ice Cream, Fruity Pebbles, Cap'n Crunch, and Milk. Topped with Whipped Cream, Crushed Fruity Pebbles, and Lucky Charms Marshmallow. Price: $12.00 Taste: I definitely tasted every cereal included. Consistency: Even with the chunks of cereal, it was a easy sip. I loved the added crunch. A ... read more
Milkshake Logs L. via yelp.com - May 3, 2022
Saturday morning is fantastic Very creamy and yummy I will come back for sure this summer
Saturday morning is fantastic Very creamy and yummy I will come back for sure this summer ... read more
Ant A. via yelp.com - Apr 30, 2022
As much as it is busy. The service is amazing has a great vibe to it and then to top that the amazing food. The worker meg was a big help with questions and her own experience for the ice cream !
Grey via google.com - Apr 23, 2022
I love how they decorate their ice cream cone. Looking forward to seeing more new flavors
I love how they decorate their ice cream cone. Looking forward to seeing more new flavors ... read more
Ellen G. via yelp.com - Apr 22, 2022
visiting Utah, Salt Lake City, and this place was truly the best ice cream I've ever had in my life.
visiting Utah, Salt Lake City, and this place was truly the best ice cream I've ever had in my life. So so many different cereal mix-ins to the only base of vanilla ice cream that they offer. Tons of delicious cones too ! Such a cute vibe inside and the workers were so so so nice :) will come back ... read more
Kylie P. via yelp.com - Apr 17, 2022
Un muy buen lugar lo recomiendo mucho Debería de aver uno en san diego California 🍦🍦 ... read more
gabriel alvarez via google.com - Apr 16, 2022
Yummy ice cream!!
Brenda Rodriguez via google.com - Apr 16, 2022
The ice cream was good! Experience was great. I wouldn’t say it’s the best ice cream I’ve ever had but not bad.
Sara via google.com - Apr 16, 2022
Discovered this spot as I was driving by. STOP and get a cone of delicious wonderfulness. Saturday Morning is Cap'n Crunch and Apple Jacks cereal blended with ice cream. Perfect treat for any reason. Don't deny yourself ... read more
Hector Montoya via google.com - Apr 16, 2022
When you first open the door it smells like Saturday morning cartoons! The delicious smells take you
When you first open the door it smells like Saturday morning cartoons! The delicious smells take you back to great childhood memories. The cashier was very friendly and accommodating. We ordered the Nuts about chocolate because it rings true to us since we LOVE all things chocolate. We're not particular fans of soft ice cream but we ... read more
James R. via yelp.com - Apr 16, 2022
Best milkshakes ever and the staff does great at not getting stressed while crazy busy ... read more
Hydrasfool (Hail Hydra) via google.com - Apr 11, 2022
I totally misunderstood what this place was when I walked in. I thought it would be a cereal bar whe
I totally misunderstood what this place was when I walked in. I thought it would be a cereal bar where you could get bowls of cereal with another bar for ice cream. However, the two merged and you actually get an ice cream cone with bits of cereal mixed in. The menu is simple-there are not too many options to choose from, which might ... read more
Nycole R. via yelp.com - Apr 11, 2022
This was the first time trying Spilled Milk and the Orange Creamsicle shake was so good! Each member of my family had something different, and everyone was impressed. The team behind the counter was great. Super friendly and patient while everyone decided what to get (everything sounded good). Would definitely recommend!
Caylyn Albarado via google.com - Apr 9, 2022
Very clean shop with nice smell and top notch icecream I would take somebody here for a date except the way I eat icecream is messy 10/10 ... read more
Darin S via google.com - Apr 8, 2022
Was traveling cross Country and my friend and I stopped here for desert. The ice cream was phenomena
Was traveling cross Country and my friend and I stopped here for desert. The ice cream was phenomenal! The staff was very friendly and helpful being it was our first time here. The only complaint I would have was it was to much ice cream but beside that I would definitely go back there and I do highly recommend this ice cream place i ... read more
Janay S. via yelp.com - Apr 2, 2022
Came on a sunny day at lunch - a lot of people inside but very quick to get my cone. I tried the strawberries with teddy grahams. Really large scoop!
Julie Baker via google.com - Apr 1, 2022
One of the best ice cream cones I've ever had!
Lynzy Morrison via google.com - Mar 24, 2022
Yummy ice cream. Perfect for the kiddos. Fun to watch! And great atmosphere.
Dominic Bohne via google.com - Mar 23, 2022
Great environment good people and It's One of the best ice cream places I've been to.
Prentice Lionel via google.com - Mar 20, 2022
Well they call me King Bear up here on Banana Mountain but if you want it you can have the crown! Bo
Well they call me King Bear up here on Banana Mountain but if you want it you can have the crown! Bomb. Bomb. Bomb. Ice Cream. I had some seasonal thing on offer with bananas and Teddy Grahams. I got a kids cup and watched them blend half of an entire banana into that bastard and top it with some bears and whipped cream. I don't know ... read more
Vasily K. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2022
Nuts for chocolate is to die for. The best ice cream place in Utah and it is very unique. Highly recommend this place.
Den Den via google.com - Mar 9, 2022
Remember that taste of the milk at the end of your best bowl of cereal? This place takes that and makes it a wonderful ice cream with your favorite flavors! Definitely worth the trip, we will be coming back, as this was definitely a "Match Made in Heaven"!
Andrew Holmes via google.com - Mar 5, 2022
This was my first time coming here! The place is super cute and the ice cream was wayyy better than
This was my first time coming here! The place is super cute and the ice cream was wayyy better than I thought it would be! A little slow but there was only one girl working but she was great!
Kenzie K. via yelp.com - Mar 4, 2022
Glad we went, our group of six loved it! Thought I'd do a group review, so read on to see what every
Glad we went, our group of six loved it! Thought I'd do a group review, so read on to see what everyone had to say... "Before going in I thought it would be gimmicky, but it's actually a really cool idea and the ice cream AND the cones are really good!" "For someone like me who only likes chocolate ice cream, the Nuts For Chocolate ( ... read more
Gwen R. via yelp.com - Mar 4, 2022
Fun environment and great shakes!
Katrina Christenson via google.com - Mar 2, 2022
Fun little ice cream shop to try. We went here on a whim and it was very good. Recommend if you want to try something new!
Makenna Merrill via google.com - Feb 28, 2022
So good! Get the Cinnamon Toast Crunch ice cream!
David Cummock via google.com - Feb 26, 2022
Decided to try some place new for dessert on vacation in SLC. Spilled Milk did not disappoint. My husband had the Over the Rainbow and I had A Match Made in Heaven, both made as a shake. The shakes were so good and tasted like childhood in a cup. 10/10 highly recommend this place to EVERYONE!
Shea Even via google.com - Feb 19, 2022
Got "Over the rainbow"🌈 and it was magically delecious ... read more
Destiny Joestar via google.com - Feb 13, 2022
Great experience, great milkshake, and a new employee (Megan) did a wonderful job!
J Beast via google.com - Feb 8, 2022
Everything about this place is great. I’ve gotten nearly everything on the menu but the match made in heaven milkshake stood out the most. Best milkshake in the state.
Ben McKeon via google.com - Feb 7, 2022
First time trying the store location and absolutely loved it! It’s so cute inside and makes for the perfect treat with family or friends. The banana dream pie is my favorite and lives up to its name. I definitely recommend if you’re looking for a sweet treat!
Tara Amador via google.com - Feb 7, 2022
Super good ice cream! The staff was less than nice and it almost felt like we were bothering them by ordering.
Hunter Ulibarri via google.com - Jan 8, 2022
Never fails to disappoint! I bring all my family here when we go out! Went in a later in the night the two guys working the shift were fast, friendly and kept the place looking clean when they're weren't helping any customers . Keep it up!!
Jose Lazalde via google.com - Jan 7, 2022
Staff were friendly and the ice cream here was 🔥 definitely a must have! If you get a normal sized cone, it’s big enough for 2 people 👍🏻 otherwise for single servings, I’d get the smaller size :) ... read more
Steven Kellogg via google.com - Dec 28, 2021
So good would definitely recommend ... read more
Ben Roberts via google.com - Dec 21, 2021
Yum yum delicious ice cream 🍦🍦 in my tummy many times worth of money 💰👍🤩🤩🤩 ... read more
Adventure Traveling via google.com - Dec 19, 2021
I LOVE this place. The over the rainbow is my favorite. Every bite tastes like a creamy bowl of fruity pebbles. 100% recommend coming here.
Rylan Gordon via google.com - Dec 19, 2021
Get the match made in heaven milkshake. Sooo good.
Briana McKeon via google.com - Dec 18, 2021
Wonderful Sundaes and Combos of Ice Cream at this place. However the sugar levels are on the higher side. If you wanna indulge and get that sugar rush type of dessert, head over here.
Rohan Srinivas via google.com - Dec 13, 2021
Very yummy and very cute😄 ... read more
Victoria Wynn via google.com - Dec 4, 2021
Great super convenient location with enough seating. The staff is kind and efficient and the flavor combinations are so creative and delicious. The atmosphere is amazing and this is a great place to go if you have a sweet tooth. They have all kinds of wonderful concoctions and a wide variety of toppings and ice creams to choose from.
Riya Menon via google.com - Dec 2, 2021
DELICIOUS 😭😭😭😭😭😭 ... read more
Charissa Mider via google.com - Nov 28, 2021
The service was excellent. Friendly, fast, helpful. The custom-built mixer machines were cool to watch. My kids loved the cones. We tried several different flavors. I had an ice cream sandwich that was huge.
Todd Beck via google.com - Nov 26, 2021
Super yummy ice cream. Wish they had a location up north!
Erin Udink via google.com - Nov 24, 2021
Pro-tip: Besides for the premade options, you can make your own. It's not well advertised, but you c
Pro-tip: Besides for the premade options, you can make your own. It's not well advertised, but you can choose an unlimited number of toppings - some can be mixed in and some are just added on top. They recommend only mixing in three different toppings though otherwise the soft serve will be gritty. Highlights: Really neat concept, bu ... read more
Winnie L. via yelp.com - Nov 14, 2021
We were in town and when I came across this place I knew that we had to stop in. First, I absolutely love local places like this! The flavors were quite unique but I settled on a fried ice cream shake and it was out of this world. The combination of ice cream and cereal is a winner every time. It was just the perfect sweet dessert th ... read more
Mark Yambor via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
I can have milk and cereal for dinner and be happy. Therefore, coming here for ice cream and cereal
I can have milk and cereal for dinner and be happy. Therefore, coming here for ice cream and cereal (for dinner or not) makes me even happier. Not only are there fun flavors of ice cream, there are also fun flavors for cones, like red velvet, coconut, orange creamsicle, or green matcha. I have not tried their milk shakes yet, but wou ... read more
Ally W. via yelp.com - Nov 11, 2021
This is a fun ice cream bar to visit for children AND adults! Spilled Milk mixes ice cream, cereal,
This is a fun ice cream bar to visit for children AND adults! Spilled Milk mixes ice cream, cereal, and classic candies with ice cream. It was a little difficult to make a decision and decided to just try a bunch. We tried the "Over the rainbow", "Match made in Heaven", and "Banana dream pie". We definitely had a great time with thes ... read more
Caroline N. via yelp.com - Nov 11, 2021
Visited on Sunday. Spent time on Salt Lake before a flight and wow. Every person I was with couldn't
Visited on Sunday. Spent time on Salt Lake before a flight and wow. Every person I was with couldn't stop talking about how amazing our dessert was. I am a cereal fanatic and this was everything. I did the make your own cone with fruit loop ice cream and lucky charm marshmallows on top. Perfection. The others got shakes (best one was ... read more
Samantha B. via yelp.com - Nov 9, 2021
Spilled Milk has such a fun idea - mixing cereal (and other toppings) in with ice cream, sort of Col
Spilled Milk has such a fun idea - mixing cereal (and other toppings) in with ice cream, sort of Coldstone-style. For a first-timer, the menu is a bit confusing and it isn't explained how the ice cream is presented (some toppings are on top, some are mixed in.) I wish they would've had a bit more breakdown on the menu or from an empl ... read more
Kelsey C. via yelp.com - Oct 30, 2021
One of the best milkshakes I have ever had!
Autumn Whittaker via google.com - Oct 26, 2021
The strawberry milkshake was so good ... read more
Una Phillips via google.com - Oct 25, 2021
I'm lactose intolerant but this ice cream was worth my stomach pains. Made with whole milk and all t
I'm lactose intolerant but this ice cream was worth my stomach pains. Made with whole milk and all the amazing toppings...I'm not creative so I had the raspberry, almond on vanilla ice cream and it was delish!! Usually ice cream at such gourmet-make-your-own types of places will be super sweet but Spilled Milk had the balance just ri ... read more
Vic P. via yelp.com - Oct 24, 2021
I came in under the impression that these guys were going to load my ice cream up with a ton of Mix-
I came in under the impression that these guys were going to load my ice cream up with a ton of Mix-ins. I have a friend that told me not to go because these guys over-do it. Now that sounded pretty darn good to me. It sounded like he was complaining that their was too much awesome in his ice cream. So I set out to obtain some of thi ... read more
Justin D. via yelp.com - Oct 22, 2021
This place is so unique and delicious. I stop by any time I'm in the area. They even have vegan opti
This place is so unique and delicious. I stop by any time I'm in the area. They even have vegan options.
Dani H. via yelp.com - Oct 13, 2021
I don't know how I have never considered combing ice cream and cereal. What a genius idea! The store itself is clean, minimally designed, and very cute. Great service and great desserts. Would recommend ... read more
Hawkin Saeger via google.com - Oct 10, 2021
It wasn't busy when we came in around 2:30p on a Thursday. The menu felt limited, but were able to f
It wasn't busy when we came in around 2:30p on a Thursday. The menu felt limited, but were able to find something that we liked. We love the different flavors and colors of the cone. They have generous size of rice Crispy Treats and Milkshakes on the menu. There weren't enough parking spots, but it didn't seem like a busy area so we' ... read more
Maria M. via yelp.com - Oct 6, 2021
Really good ice cream!! This is a cool spot with creative ice cream cones and shakes. I recommend th
Really good ice cream!! This is a cool spot with creative ice cream cones and shakes. I recommend the kids one bc it was only $4 and it was still plenty big. It was kind of a long wait but they were working hard to get them out as quickly as possible. It was just a really busy night so not going to hold it against them. $7 for regula ... read more
Austin G. via yelp.com - Oct 2, 2021
Delicious. Instagram-worthy. Open late. The three best ways to describe this place! Definitely check
Delicious. Instagram-worthy. Open late. The three best ways to describe this place! Definitely check it out if you're in SLC.
Amanda R. via yelp.com - Sep 29, 2021
Such a cute place and significantly more enjoyable than I expected. I didn't expect the cereal to li
Such a cute place and significantly more enjoyable than I expected. I didn't expect the cereal to literally be blended into the ice cream, but it was great. I also felt that the price was reasonable for the amount of ice cream you receive. I was stuffed after eating it. The people behind the counter were kind and quick. I'd definitel ... read more
Corinn S. via yelp.com - Sep 18, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire